| | | |

How News and TV Shape the Way We See Disability with Dr. Beth Haller

How the Media Shapes Our Views on Disability with Dr. Beth Haller

In this guest-hosted episode, Leah Smith sits down with Dr. Beth Haller, media scholar and co-founder of the Global Alliance for Disability in Media and Entertainment (GADIM), to talk about how news and entertainment shape public perception of disability.

Beth traces her path from print journalist to researcher, explains what the disability rights movement lost when it stepped away from the media after the ADA passed, and looks back at television history from Life Goes On to Designing Women. She also shares the story behind the Props No More documentary and the Global Disability News Network, and why media skills training matters for people with disabilities.

Chapters
0:00 Welcome and cold open
0:48 Introducing Dr. Beth Haller
2:35 From print journalist to disability media scholar
4:05 How the ADA story was lost in the media
6:10 Inside the newsroom: Bloom County and inspiration porn
9:14 Why media representation matters: Parenthood
13:00 Founding GADIM at the United Nations
15:30 Life Goes On and Chris Burke’s self-advocacy
18:35 How the AIDS crisis reshaped TV storylines
25:10 Why disability stories deserve retelling
27:44 Building the Global Disability News Network and Props No More
31:58 One piece of advice for journalists

Watch the Episode here:

Listen to the episode on your favorite podcast player:

Karina Sturm: Welcome to TGDNN, a podcast powered by GADIM, the Global Alliance for Disability in Media and Entertainment. I’m Karina Sturm, co-host of this podcast and news director of the Global Disability News Network. We hope you enjoy this guest episode, featuring an interview conducted by Leah Smith with Beth Haller, founder of GADIM.

Beth Haller: People are afraid for their own bodies and minds. And so when they see somebody with a visible disability, all they can think of is, “Oh my God, I could never live like that.” And I want to say, “Oh, you don’t know how resilient you could be.”

Leah Smith: Hello, everyone. We are so excited to be here today, but even more excited to be joined by Dr. Beth Haller, who is personally one of my mentors and one of my favorite people on the planet, to be honest, but also the queen when it comes to media representation and disability. So who better to talk to than Beth herself? So let me give you a little bit of background. Beth has spent more than three decades examining how news and entertainment shape public perception of disability. Her work has been foundational in pushing media towards more accurate, ethical, and inclusive storytelling. She’s the author of Disabled People Transforming Media Culture for a More Inclusive World, co-founder of the Global Alliance for Disability in Media and Entertainment, and the creator and producer of Props No More, a project dedicated to challenging the use of disabled people as props in media narratives. Her research, teaching, and advocacy have influenced journalists, filmmakers, policymakers, and students around the globe. Without further ado, we’re so thrilled to have you. Thank you so much.

Beth Haller: Thank you very much.

Leah Smith: So I want to jump in. I have so many questions for you, and then I want to finish off with a lightning round of quick questions, just one or a couple word answers, but that’ll be at the end. So let’s start with your, we’ll start with your teaching and your books, and then we’ll go into Props No More and some of those things. So you spent a lot of time looking at disability and journalism and media. What initially drew you to this, and what keeps you committed to it today?

Beth Haller: So I was a print journalist back in the 1980s, and I was disability ignorant, I would say, back then. But I did stories related to disabled people, and that got me thinking about disability. And then when I went and got my master’s in journalism at the University of Maryland, College Park, I found out about the Society for Disability Studies and ended up doing my master’s thesis on the media coverage in the New York Times and Washington Post before, during, and after Deaf President Now, which was in 1988. And then I enjoy teaching. I had a chance to teach some when I was getting my master’s. I went to my first Society for Disability Studies meeting in Rockville, Maryland. I was like, “Ooh, I found my people.” But it was great, except there were very few people in the Society for Disability Studies back then that cared about media, because there was this disconnect, I think, between understanding how we can make change and how we need to have the media be part of that. So in the disability rights movement of the seventies and eighties, when they finally got the ADA, the Americans with Disabilities Act, passed, they thought they could walk away from the media, and the disability rights advocates, a lot of them actually said

Leah Smith: we did wrong.

Beth Haller: Still, it had a long impact, because a big, important law like the Americans with Disabilities Act was going to change society. But if disabled people and disability organizations were not going to give their side of the story, the business community jumped in and said, “Oh, this is an unfunded mandate.” That was what they used back then. And so they didn’t know why everything was trashed

Leah Smith: in the media,

Beth Haller: and it was because there were no voices from the disability community. And somebody asked me that at one of my first SDS meetings, “Well, yeah, that’s great, the media’s great, but we’ve got to get people out of institutions and into schools and jobs and all that.” And my answer was, “How do you think you’re going to do all that without public opinion being on your side?” And so there was, like I said, this big disconnect, because so few people were doing media stuff, which has come full circle now. I just love seeing how many young graduate students are looking at media and disability, people in all these other countries. And so I think finally everyone knows, and the media has changed so much. People see how it has impacted them just with smartphones and the whole nine yards of new media. So I think things started to get better

Leah Smith: when

Beth Haller: we started acknowledging as the disability community that our voices need to be heard. And also, since I’d been a print journalist, I kind of knew how journalists thought, and journalists actually want to do a story about something like disability rights, because that’s a good story. It’s newsworthy. But a lot of the editors want to do one of those “Ooh, look, a child in a wheelchair sitting before a fountain with an ice cream cone” in that paper [verify]. That was actually a Bloom County cartoon. Berkeley Breathed did this cartoon, which was this little girl sitting in front of a pretty mountain, pretty fountain, and she has an ice cream cone. She’s sitting in a wheelchair, and he’s holding the picture in front of an editor. It was something that was really commentary way long ago about how the media liked inspiration porn. They wanted that feature on the front page, because they all thought disability was such a downer, and so they wanted something happy or light or whatever. And so I think that was kind of really important, to bring what I knew about the inside of the newsroom. And also, I remember somebody I knew in Texas. Her husband loved to write letters to the editor back in the day, and finally, I forget what newspaper, it was one of the bigger ones in Texas, they had to bar him to no more than one letter per month, because he was sending in one every day. And the old quote about the power of the press goes to the one who owns one is very true, and still true today as we see who owns all of our media. So I think I’m kind of more hopeful now that we have a lot of people looking at it, and also just the media being such a godsend for the disability community. Once the internet came in, people started doing research about how it could change people’s lives. And yes, it did, but was the internet 1.0 that helpful? And then there’s always the backlash too. So, “Oh, you can shop online. We don’t have to make our store accessible to you.” So there’s always the dark side of everything good that happens.

Leah Smith: Right.

Beth Haller: And I think also, I think that now, with my recent book and everything that’s happening now, I think we just have to focus on disabled people and them telling their own stories, because I’ve been trying to educate the media world for a long time, and it doesn’t stick very well. The

Leah Smith: people. Well, why do, I mean, I feel like this is obvious maybe to you and I, but maybe not to other people. Why does media representation of disabled people matter?

Beth Haller: Because it affects people’s self-identity and their family, and the interactions they have with people in the public. And I mean, just like everything, it’s a TV show with a very horribly bad disabled character with a very specific disability. Let’s say autism. I’m thinking of Parenthood with the autistic kid. He was so unpleasant, and most autistic people I know are very pleasant people to be around. [verify]

Clip from Parenthood: Max. Yeah. You did a really good job planning for the sleepover. Thank you. I love it. I love it. Hey, buddy, I have some bad news. There’s been a change in plan, and Jabbar can’t come. Yes, yes, he can. He’s flying tomorrow. It’s 9:32, arriving Oakland International Airport, 5:45 PM. Okay, but he changed plans. Now he, he has a ticket. Yeah, but there was a change of plan. No. I’m sure he can come back again soon, right? Yeah, hopefully. But who knows what, what. No, this is un

Beth Haller: And I think he was joking with his dad that he wanted to sue him for mining his life for his TV show. His dad was like, “Ha ha, ha ha.” I’m like, “No, I think you should get a lawyer.” And so he’s making big bucks as a showrunner on Parenthood. But anyway, and he documented what he was doing. “Ha ha ha ha, my son wants to sue me, because I put an autistic character in there based on him.”

Leah Smith: I’m like,

Beth Haller: yeah. His father thought he knew about somebody with autism. Think about how different that show would’ve been if there’d been an actual autistic kid or an autistic adult playing an autistic character. So I think it affects all of us culturally. It’s what people, if you say, “Give me an example of a famous wheelchair user,” people, if they’re into sports, they might cite a Paralympian. If they’re into YouTube shows, they might cite Teal Sherer, who’s an actual disabled actor who’s a wheelchair user. If they’re a film person, they’re mostly going to see non-disabled white men who want to die portraying wheelchair users. And I think that has a very long life in all of our cultures, where people are afraid for their own bodies and minds. And so when they see somebody with a visible disability, all they can think of is, “Oh my God, I could never live like that.” And I want to say, “Oh, you don’t know how resilient you could be.”

Leah Smith: Right. And you also don’t know how good life could be. I think that people think disability is so terrible and so awful. They don’t have any idea about disability joy and disability community and disability, Ja [verify], all the things that come, all the good parts of disability as well. Okay. So did you write your book first or start GADIM first? I get the two confused.

Beth Haller: Okay. So Patricia Almeida, Catia Malaquias, and I started it. Pat had the idea for GADIM, Global Alliance for Disability in Media and Entertainment, and so she came to two of us. I actually introduced Pat and Catia. Pat is from Brazil. Catia lives in Western Australia, but her family immigrated there from Portugal, so they speak Portuguese in Brazil, so that was very easy to make them best friends. They both have a child with Down syndrome. One is now 21 and one is still a teenager. But anyway, so they had their own interest, and of course I had my research interest and community interest. And so 2016 was the anniversary of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. So Pat’s very plugged into the UN and other things. She and her husband worked in the Brazilian consulate. So she said, “Let’s get on the agenda, and we can launch GADIM and talk about the importance of media,” because the UN Convention says that part of disability rights is raising awareness in a society. And how do you do that? Use the media. And even way back in the late nineties, somebody from, I think, Rehabilitation International wrote a video catalog of films and TV series from around the world. I referred to this in my book, my 2023 book, that people were getting an idea of, “Oh, this is interesting.” And there were non-disabled filmmakers and TV showrunners and people with family members with disabilities that knew how important it was to represent people with disabilities. We get a show like Life Goes On that started in 1989 and starred Chris Burke as a young man with Down syndrome, and Chris Burke has Down syndrome. And I thought that was a really interesting kind of example of how things can start really great, and then they kind of fall away because something else happens. And in the olden days, there was a show called The Fall Guy, and a kid with Down syndrome had a guest starring role on one episode. Chris Burke is living in New York City, I think, and very into performing and theater camps and all that kind of thing. He’s working as a elevator operator. And so he sees this kid on The Fall Guy and writes a letter to the, he’s 18 at this point, so he’s an adult. Writes a letter to the showrunner, whoever, of The Fall Guy. Gets the letter back. And so he and his brother go out to Hollywood, and I think he did a guest starring role, and they were really taken with him, and they said, “We want to build a show around you.” And so he advocated for himself and said, “Look, I’m a person with Down syndrome. I have intellectual disability, so I cannot memorize 42 pages of a script for a TV show.” And I think it actually is good that he said that, because I think that’s important, that he was standing up for what he needed, but it also made it a better show, because they made it a family drama. They had his sister characters, his girlfriend, his sister’s boyfriend, and they started kind of an interesting, you could have seen this happening in any family in America, because what was happening was he was older than the Kellie Martin sister. So she played his younger sister, Becca, and so she was 14 and starting high school, and Corky, the Chris Burke character, was like 16 or 17 and starting high school, because he was being mainstreamed. And so right off the bat, that’s interesting, having a sister who’s not, this is not her twin, starting school. Right. And so it’s complex. And she was actually a teenager herself, so she kind of, she and Chris Burke are still friends, because this was an older teenager that she looked up to, and she was on set with him for four years. But then what happened, and I have to credit Gail Williamson, who’s the Hollywood agent for many disabled performers for many years. She’s now retired. But anyway,

Leah Smith: when

Beth Haller: I interviewed her for my book, she said, “You know what happened?” She also has a son who has Down syndrome who’s an actor. She said what happened was the AIDS crisis, so suddenly that is all over the news. It’s everywhere. And so Hollywood responds to what’s in the kind of zeitgeist. Back in the olden days, everybody who worked on a TV set, whatever job, probably read the newspaper before they went in to the studio. And so even Life Goes On, that’s why I use it as an example, switched to focusing on Becca’s boyfriend, played by Chad Lowe. I think his name is Chad, right? Chad Lowe, Rob Lowe’s younger brother. They never really explained how he got it. They were a little kind of iffy there. But I don’t even think they were at the point of calling it HIV positive yet. But anyway, that was, of course, it added lots of drama. They made him a regular character, and then Corky was close friends with him, but still it became Becca’s, and I found a lot of writing about it when I was doing my book too. And so the Jesse character got a lot of airtime, story time. And then she said Chad Lowe wins an Emmy. So then everybody’s like, “Ooh, we’ve got to work AIDS into our show.” And people like Linda Bloodworth-Thomason, who did Designing Women, so she’s from Arkansas, and her mother died of AIDS in a hospital wing with lots of gay men, and she was being treated just like the gay men, and the nurses would not go in there and stuff. And so she wrote the first, I think, real TV series acknowledgement of AIDS, and it was with Designing Women. And I think Tony Goldwyn played the gay man who goes to the Designing Women’s interior design company and says, “I have AIDS. I’m going to die. I want you to plan my funeral,” or whatever. I think it was his funeral, something that he wanted them to design, because he knew, I mean, what was happening back then was that funeral homes would not take a body of somebody who had died of AIDS. Sometimes they had to go sneak them into the back door of a funeral home that would take anybody. I read this book about this woman who took care of the, I read a lot, as you know, I’m blanking on the name of it. But anyway, a woman in Arkansas who just started taking care of gay men, because it was the right thing to do. She was visiting a friend in the hospital, and somebody on that unit had AIDS, and no one was going in there, and they were just leaving the food tray outside. So she goes in and opens the door, and she’s like, “Did anybody put your food on your tray for you?” And she makes friends with all these guys, and she started making casseroles and figuring out, finding them houses. And also, I mean, it was really interesting, because that’s what was happening. Everyone thought that AIDS was in New York and Miami and San Francisco and Los Angeles, but you didn’t have any family there, and your partner may have died. You went back home to your hometown, and if that’s Arkansas, I mean, there was a line directly from this woman in Arkansas to Bill Clinton, because when he became governor, she started writing him letters. She knew him a little bit as a teenager. He was older than her, but her father was in the political stuff, and he was a known itch teeth [verify] when he was a teenager in Arkansas. But it’s like she went to his inauguration, because he got educated from those letters that she sent. And so then it all filters out through the culture, and we’re lucky if it gets to a president or a showrunner or somebody that can talk about it. But I found some essays by gay men, and one of them, he was talking about, he was a teenager, he knew he was gay, but he saw that episode of Designing Women, and he is like, “Look, I’m being represented.” I think that always needs to be happening. We need to have people representing these issues and disabilities, and an AIDS diagnosis is covered by the ADA, even though some of the center [verify] just didn’t want it. And thankfully it is, because now being HIV positive is kind of a chronic illness for a lot of people. There’s medication, and you just take it for the rest of your life, and you’re fine. But there’s still a group of people that don’t respond to the medication, so just like any long-term illness. Anyway, so just getting that information out into the culture is really important, and also it needs to be accurate information.

Leah Smith: I was having a conversation just yesterday about how so often people think that disabled stories are only for disabled people, or that we could maybe tell one story about someone in a wheelchair, but then that’s enough. We don’t need to keep going with that, right? And yet we can tell the same rom-com story 150 times on the Hallmark Channel and nobody gets tired. We all know the ending, and nobody gets tired of it, nor is anyone stopped from telling the story again. But somehow when it comes to disability, we’re really like, “Oh, we can only tell that once, like once every 10 years or something.” And one person can tell it. Okay, so you start the Global Alliance for Disability in Media and Entertainment with Pat and Catia, and that’s really just the seed, because then you go on and, what I like to call it, you started your own empire.

Beth Haller: I wish.

Leah Smith: And from there you started the project of Props No More, the documentary, which will soon be in post-production, not in post-production yet, but will soon be in post-production and then released, hopefully in 2027, which is all about disabled media creators, by disabled media creators, and by a whole disabled crew, which is in and of itself really cool. And then from that, that launched into a platform, the Props No More platform, which is all about education and accessibility and the global reach of the Props platform. But then what I don’t think a lot of people know is there’s a lot of other projects that are coming out of that as well. There’s In the Midst [verify], which I’ll let you tell about. I’m getting so excited, because I want to tell about all of these. And then there’s the Global Disability News Network. So when I say that you’ve started an empire, you have truly started an empire. So please tell us first, tell us about the Global Disability News Network, and then tell us about In the Midst [verify] and even Props. I don’t want to by any means put a shadow on any of these things. They’re such great projects.

Beth Haller: Yeah. So when I finished my book in 2023, I was like, “This is great. I got a bunch of people’s stories out there in book form.” But then I thought, there’s still so many people that, we’re a visual world now, so I really wanted to move toward some way to get people onto a screen, so that people could hear from them and that kind of thing. So I contacted my friend Karina Sturm, who has a master’s in journalism, and part of her master’s, she did a documentary on Ehlers-Danlos syndrome, which she has. And it was about people with EDS in several different countries. She’s from Germany, and there are still countries that don’t believe EDS exists yet. So it was really important. And so we did a screening of that in 2020, right before the pandemic, in Southern California, and like a hundred people show up, and we’re like saying, “We need to show this in medical schools and nursing schools. This is really important.” They finally felt seen. It was just amazing to see all these people suddenly feel seen, and then that’s it. We don’t see, I guess, two different EDS people on Raisin [verify]. That’s as far as they’ve come.

Leah Smith: Wow. No, that’s, I mean, the fact that that’s as far, yeah.

Beth Haller: So I start talking to her, and she moved into doing some short docs and working with a great team in Germany. So we started putting together ideas, and I had this film treatment that I put together that had I don’t know, 30 people being interviewed. They’re like, “That doesn’t really work, and everybody gets three seconds.” So they rewrote me, which I was very happy about. And we got down to kind of about eight primary stories, primary and secondary stories of disabled journalists, disabled actors, disabled experts, disabled filmmakers, advocates, you name it. So just kind of people that would have lots of opinions, but are also working in the media as well. So we start that in 2024, and I’m learning all that documentary filmmaking as we go. And we do the US shoot. We filmed in Germany, the Netherlands, England, the US, and Canada, and then other countries are talked about too. We did the US shoot in the fall of 2024. Now we’re finishing up one more shoot that we have to do, and then we’ll be officially in post-production. But while we’re waiting, once we were done and they’re sitting over there a step, I’m like, “We need to keep this in people’s minds.” And it just showed me the media skills are something very tangible and useful for disabled people to get training in. So if you’re a really good audio person, that’s all anybody cares about, that you’re getting excellent sound quality. So I was like, “Why can’t we provide that kind of educational content, so people anywhere in the world could watch a video about how to mic somebody, what to look out for to get the best audio, how to be a good editor, that kind of thing?” So that was my idea to start that kind of project.

Leah Smith: Okay. Last question. If you could give one sentence of advice to any journalist covering disability, what would it be?

Beth Haller: Talk to a disabled person. If your story is about any kind of disability topic, or even if it isn’t, talk to a disabled person. Like, if they’re building a new kindergarten or building a new elementary school in a neighborhood, you need to be asking what accessibility features it has, because it’s not supposed to be built without accessibility features, because this is 2025. Or if you’re doing a renovation of a public space, it is supposed to be made accessible. So I think just get in the habit of asking a disabled person.

Links:

GADIM (Global Alliance for Disability in Media and Entertainment): Beth’s organization and organization of behind the podcast https://gadim.org/

Props No More: GADIM’s documentary and education platform. https://propsnomore.org/

Global Disability News Network: https://globaldisabilitynews.org/

Dr. Beth Haller: Beth’s website, research, and CV. https://bethhaller.wordpress.com/

Disabled People Transforming Media Culture for a More Inclusive World – Beth’s book discussed in the episode https://www.routledge.com/Disabled-People-Transforming-Media-Culture-for-a-More-Inclusive-World/Haller/p/book/9781032106625

Related Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *